First Team |
| Tyler Bogus - Buckeye |
| Kyle DiCapua - Lutheran West |
| Jacob Miller - Columbia |
| Colin Miller - Buckeye |
| Jacob Simon - Columbia |
| Zach Stopper - Columbia |
| Tim Straka - Fairview |
|
Second Team |
| Mark Anderson - Brooklyn |
| Bradley Clanin - Keystone |
| Corey Hayden - Buckeye |
| Robert Konstan - Lutheran West |
| Caleb Peterson - Firelands |
| John Riley - Fairview |
|
