First Team |
| Blake Beard - Fairview |
| Aaron Beckman - Lutheran West |
| Joe Butti - Wellington |
| Iven Chaqueco - Fairview |
| Dakota D-Fox - Keystone |
| Jacob Dickel - Buckeye |
| Goalie Storm Ferguson - Oberlin |
| Collin Fitzgerald - Keystone |
| Ryan Grauel - Buckeye |
| Logan Johnston - Fairview |
| James Keressi - Firelands |
| Brandon Kmitt - Brookside |
| Sam Levine - Oberlin |
| Liam McMillin - Oberlin |
| Dan Oswalt - Buckeye |
| Goalie Logan Priddy - Keystone |
| Sam Salay - Brooklyn |
| Viktor Thrane - Columbia |
| Nick Vrabel - Lutheran West |
| Tony Walker - Wellington |
| Sam Weiss - Oberlin |
| Nate Yorks - Firelands |
| Tyler Yurik - Buckeye |
| Matt Zelinsky - Columbia |
|
Second Team |
| Mitch Boehmke - Buckeye |
| Morgan Bremke - Oberlin |
| Tristan Clark - Firelands |
| Ryan Cobb - Buckeye |
| Tim Coulter - Lutheran West |
| Mike Dowdell - Wellington |
| Mike Faler - Lutheran West |
| Josh Gentile - Brooklyn |
| Goalie Connor Gibbons - Fairview |
| Turner Giesel - Keystone |
| Chris Jones - Brookside |
| Kyle Jones - Brookside |
| Ian Lara - Wellington |
| Jack McMillin - Oberlin |
| Goalie Jake Miller - Wellington |
| Josh Piotrowski - Keystone |
| Tom Protzman - Oberlin |
| Kyle Starks - Fairview |
| Gus Tapper - Firelands |
| Mike Wilkinson - Fairview |
| David Wos - Columbia |
|
Honorable Mention |
| Ahmed Eddeb - Brooklyn |
| Ian Farago - Wellington |
| Nate Hite - Columbia |
| Zack Jones - Fairview |
| Dante LaRiccia - Oberlin |
| Cody Rising - Keystone |
| Jordan Ruffner - Firelands |
| George Rusinko - Buckeye |
| Florian Schultz - Brookside |
| Pat Smith - Lutheran West |
|
